Watch the video:
A Career Of The Badge, Ended By An Indictment
David Agosto spent 24 years as an NYPD officer before coming to Florida and taking a job as a Pasco County sheriff’s deputy. Fifty-seven years old, a lifetime in law enforcement — and according to a Hernando County grand jury, a secret running the entire time.
On August 18, that grand jury returned a six-count indictment against him. The top count: sexual battery on a person under 12 years old. Under Florida’s 2023 law, that charge is capital — one of the only crimes in the state where prosecutors can still seek the death penalty.
It Started With A Tip
The investigation opened July 29, when Hernando County Sheriff’s detectives received a tip about a juvenile victim. According to the arrest affidavit, the child was known to Agosto — this was not a stranger. Detectives say the alleged abuse happened on multiple occasions, and that the victim’s account was corroborated in part by witnesses and by records pulled from Agosto’s own phone.
The custodial-authority wording in the indictment counts matters. Florida law treats offenses committed by someone who has authority over a child as an aggravating factor — and a lawman’s badge is exactly that.
The Search Warrant Found Something Else
When detectives executed a search warrant at Agosto’s home, they found more than evidence of the alleged abuse. More than 160 grams of marijuana, packaged with paraphernalia that detectives say pointed to intent to sell. The career lawman was, according to the charge, a drug dealer on the side. He was booked into the Hernando County Detention Facility on the original charges; the grand jury’s indictment later consolidated the case to six counts.
What Happens Next
Prosecutors have not announced whether they will seek the death penalty — that decision remains pending. Agosto’s arraignment is expected in the coming weeks, and this story will be updated as the case moves.
The badge sequence tells its own story: 24 years enforcing the law in New York, a deputy’s uniform in Pasco County, and now a capital indictment in Hernando. If even half the affidavit is proven, the system that trusted him with authority over children missed it for decades.
RAW:
Sources: Hernando County Sheriff’s Office press release (Aug 27, 2026); FOX 13 Tampa Bay; rNews; Hernando Sun.
From patrol car to patrol of a childhood
The employment history is what makes the custodial counts land differently. David Agosto, 57, served as an NYPD officer and later as a Pasco County deputy — two agencies, decades apart, both built on the same premise: an adult wearing authority a child is taught never to question. Prosecutors did not need to invent symbolism; the grand jury built it into the charging structure itself. Florida law carries enhanced counts for abuse committed by a person who holds custodial authority over the victim, and the six-count indictment uses them: two counts of sexual battery by a person in custodial authority on a victim twelve to sixteen, two lewd-or-lascivious battery counts on the same age band, a capital sexual battery count on a child under twelve, and a lewd-or-lascivious count to match.
According to the probable cause affidavit reporting, the victim disclosed abuse beginning when she was under twelve and continuing across multiple occasions — someone she knew, in the place where children are supposed to be safest. A forensic interview at the Child Protection Team reportedly found her statements consistent, and witnesses corroborated parts of the timeline.
The traffic stop that started it
The case did not begin with the abuse allegations at all — it began with a tip, and then with a search warrant that turned up more than 163 grams of marijuana packaged in individual sale bags along with paraphernalia, adding intent-to-sell counts to the file. That detail matters beyond irony. Cases like this almost never arrive with a witness walking into a sheriff’s office on day one; they arrive as fragments — a tip here, a package count there — and the agencies that act on the fragments are the reason the full picture eventually exists. Hernando County detectives opened the sexual battery investigation on July 29 and had Agosto in custody the same day.
On August 18, a grand jury returned the six-count indictment, upgrading the case from an affidavit to a true bill. Arraignment had not appeared on the Hernando Clerk’s docket when last checked, but Florida felony arraignment typically follows an indictment within about 30 days — meaning the next formal step lands mid-September.
What the capital count actually means
The under-twelve count is the one that changes everything about how this case will be prosecuted. Florida is one of the few states where that category of offense carries a potential sentence structure that ranges up to the state’s most severe penalties, and capital-grade prosecution brings a different pace, different defense funding, and a different kind of plea calculus. Most defendants facing that count resolve the case rather than run it to a jury. Watch the arraignment and the first docket changes after it — the entries there will tell you which way this is heading long before any trial date is set.
The pattern underneath is one this desk keeps documenting: the authority uniform is not protection from prosecution — in the era of Flock camera audits and digital paper trails, it increasingly points investigators straight at the man who wore it. If you have information about a case like this, the Hernando County Sheriff’s Office tip line takes calls around the clock.
Charges are allegations, and Agosto is presumed innocent unless convicted. This story will be updated when arraignment is scheduled.
Every story like this starts the same way: someone typed a name, a plate, an address — and the databases already had it. Yours does too. Optery shows you exactly which sites are selling your personal info and scrubs you off them automatically. Free scan, paid plans do the removal. We earn a commission if you sign up — it costs you nothing extra.
