Skip to content
-
Subscribe to our newsletter & never miss our best posts. Subscribe Now!
  • https://www.facebook.com/
  • https://twitter.com/
  • https://t.me/
  • https://www.instagram.com/
  • https://youtube.com/
odr avatar gray Oh Dang, Really?

Government misconduct, tracked daily. Cops fired, deputies charged, officials convicted, prison abuses exposed — sourced and updated as cases move.

odr avatar gray Oh Dang, Really?

Government misconduct, tracked daily. Cops fired, deputies charged, officials convicted, prison abuses exposed — sourced and updated as cases move.

  • Home
  • Developing
  • The Docket
  • Fired & Charged
  • Prisons
  • Flock Scandal
  • Convicted
  • About
  • Contact
  • Home
  • Developing
  • The Docket
  • Fired & Charged
  • Prisons
  • Flock Scandal
  • Convicted
  • About
  • Contact
Subscribe
Close

Search

Officer Trenton Garner filed a qualified immunity motion in the HeeHaw donkey lawsuit - and the new filings say his body camera was never rolling during the midnight search.
DevelopingFired & Charged

He Wants Immunity In The HeeHaw Donkey Case – And The New Filings Say His Bodycam Was Off

By news
October 29, 2026 2 Min Read
Comments Off on He Wants Immunity In The HeeHaw Donkey Case – And The New Filings Say His Bodycam Was Off

The officer who fired on HeeHaw the donkey during a midnight search for a missing girl now wants a federal judge to shield him personally from the family’s lawsuit — and new court filings say his body camera was never rolling that night.

Cedartown Officer Trenton Garner filed a qualified immunity motion in late October, asking the court to toss the Israel family’s $1 million federal lawsuit against him personally. The argument: no reasonable officer would have known that firing on a pet donkey — during a search for a missing 12-year-old — violated clearly established law.

The new filings add a second problem for the record. Garner’s body camera was not running during the August 30 search, according to court filings first reported by Atlanta-area stations. The bodycam record released in recent weeks does catch one thing on tape — Garner’s answer of “I don’t know” when asked about the moment — but the key stretch of that night came back silent, because the camera was never rolling.

The full timeline, as established in court records: August 30 — a drone overhead, a failed Taser attempt, a police dog on the fence line, all hunting for missing 12-year-old Hannah Israel in the dark. Somewhere in that midnight pasture, Garner fired on HeeHaw, the Israel family’s bottle-raised miniature donkey. The girl was found safe that same night. The round ended the donkey’s life.

In September, the family sued in federal court — a Fourth Amendment seizure claim under Section 1983, seeking $1 million from Garner personally. His first move in the case was a motion to dismiss. The immunity claim is the second.

To date, Garner faces no criminal cruelty charges and has not been fired — he remains on administrative leave while the immunity fight plays out. The case has drawn national attention: CBS covered the immunity dispute this week, and a Cato Institute commentary ran under the headline “No Justice for Heehaw.”

So does qualified immunity fit what happened in that midnight pasture — or does a jury deserve this one? That call now belongs to a federal judge in Georgia.

Tags:

Cedartown Georgiafederal lawsuitFourth AmendmentHannah IsraelHeeHawHeeHaw the donkeyOhDangReallypolice accountabilityPolk County GASection 1983Trenton Garner
Author

news

Follow Me
Other Articles
Previous

Texas Trooper Fernando Gomez Arrested For DWI, Kept Working 2 Months

Fired deputy Nolan Dudik, accused of AI nude images of coworkers and juvenile Explorers, arrested by Nebraska State Patrol two days after the county commission upheld his termination.
Next

Douglas County Deputy Fired Over AI Nude Images Arrested By State Patrol

Recent Posts

  • Charlottesville Officer Darius Nash Charged After K-9 Blue’s Patrol Car Welfare Case
  • Missouri Deputy David Blankenship And Wife Admit Plotting Abuse Of An 11-Year-Old
  • Wildwood Officer Todd Peck Arrested In Colleague Database Probe
  • 3 Georgia Officers Charged In Flock Camera Scandal
  • Stamford Officer Driton Xhema Charged With Stalking, Database Misuse

Categories

  • Convicted
  • Developing
  • Fired & Charged
  • Flock Camera Scandal
  • Prison & Corrections
  • Uncategorized
☕ Support the Desk
Every tip funds records requests, digging, and server time.
Privacy Policy · Privacy Tools
· Editorial Standards
Copyright 2026 — Oh Dang, Really?. All rights reserved. Blogsy WordPress Theme