St. Lucie Detective Tyler Horstman Charged With Felony DUI In Agency Truck Crash
A St. Lucie County Sheriff’s detective is facing a felony DUI charge after an off-duty wreck in Vero Beach — and police say he was driving the agency’s own truck at nearly twice the posted speed, with an alcohol level more than three times Florida’s legal limit.
Detective Tyler August Horstman, 30, was charged with driving under the influence causing serious bodily injury. According to Vero Beach police findings described in published reporting, the collision happened around 11:25 p.m. on March 1, 2026, at Beachland Boulevard and State Road A1A. Horstman was off duty, driving an unmarked sheriff’s office Ford pickup, traveling about 63 mph in a 35-mph zone.
Here’s the part investigators documented: Horstman had a green light. The other driver entered the intersection against a red one. And that car carried 20-year-old Mariana Jimenez and a 1-year-old child.
Jimenez reportedly suffered a traumatic brain injury. The child was evaluated and reportedly was not hurt. Horstman had to be extricated from his truck. His reported alcohol level: 0.246 — more than three times the 0.08 threshold.
The Employment Timeline Nobody Can Explain
Horstman was hired by the St. Lucie County Sheriff’s Office on June 18, 2021. The agency’s 2022 annual report lists him among District Patrol Night 1 personnel receiving a unit citation.
Then: February 1, 2024 — he resigned. June 3, 2024 — the same agency hired him back.
TCPalm obtained those dates from sheriff’s Capt. Andrew Bolonka, who said he did not know the circumstances behind the resignation and rehiring. No verified evidence reviewed establishes that the departure involved misconduct — but nobody at the agency can explain it either.
The Response
The sheriff’s office says it was notified of Horstman’s blood-test result on September 9. Paid administrative leave began September 15 — six days after that notification. On October 26, a felony arrest warrant was issued. Horstman surrendered, posted $15,000 bond, and was placed on unpaid administrative leave. His reported arraignment date is December 9, 2026.
“I recognize the seriousness of the allegations involving one of our deputies and the concerns this raises for our community and the members of our agency,” Sheriff Richard Del Toro said in a statement. “We hold our personnel to high standards of conduct, both on and off duty.”
Vero Beach police are the lead criminal investigators. The sheriff’s office says its internal investigation is on hold pending the criminal proceedings.
What Remains Unanswered
Why did Horstman resign in 2024 — and why did the same agency hand him a badge back four months later? What work restrictions applied after the crash, if any? And why did paid leave begin six days after the agency learned the test result?
Horstman is presumed innocent unless proven guilty. The blood alcohol, speed and crash findings above are attributed to investigators — they are not findings of guilt.
Data brokers sell your name, address, phone number and family list to anyone with a few dollars — accountability stories like this are just the visible tip. Optery finds every site exposing your info, and the paid plans scrub you off them automatically — removal is the part that actually protects you. The free scan shows you how exposed you already are. We earn a commission if you subscribe — it costs you nothing extra.