Albuquerque Pays Victim $950K Over Crash Caused By Ex-Police Chief Harold Medina
Albuquerque has agreed to pay Todd Perchert $950,000 to settle the lawsuit over a February 2024 collision caused by then-Police Chief Harold Medina — a chief whose only discipline for the wreck was two letters of reprimand.
It was February 17, 2024. Medina, with his wife riding in an unmarked APD truck, was heading to a mayoral news conference when gunfire broke out near a stop on Alvarado, according to the lawsuit. He sped away from it, ran a red light, and slammed into the driver’s side of a gold 1966 Ford Mustang at a Central Avenue intersection.
Behind the wheel of that Mustang was Todd Perchert, headed to a meetup with his Mustang club. The car had belonged to his uncle. The lawsuit and coverage of the case describe eight broken ribs, a collapsed lung, a broken collarbone and shoulder blade, and seven hours of surgery that left titanium plates holding his ribs together.
The chief’s lapel camera was off — a policy violation he discovered himself and reported, requesting the internal review. Internal Affairs found two policy violations. The consequence: two letters of reprimand. Perchert’s wife, Danielle, said the findings confirmed “the chief’s complete disregard for the rules” and that a written reprimand “pales in comparison” to the lifelong trauma. Prosecutors declined criminal charges, with the state justice department citing duress from the nearby gunfire.
Medina retired that December with the mayor’s public gratitude. This year he took on a national role developing leadership programs for police chiefs across the country. The city, meanwhile, will pay Perchert $950,000 — a settlement that admits no fault — from a city that paid out millions more across the same two fiscal years.
The family’s attorney, James Tawney, pressed the question that still has no satisfying answer: why did the department investigate its own chief instead of handing it to state police?
Image credits: 1966 Mustang photo CC BY-SA 4.0 via Wikimedia Commons (Petersen Automotive Museum); Albuquerque skyline CC BY-SA via Wikimedia Commons; remaining photos from public press events and news coverage.