Broken Arrow Police Chief Put On Leave After Warrantless Home Entry Email Surfaces
BROKEN ARROW, Okla. — A police chief told his officers they could walk into a home without a warrant. When an open records request dragged that advice into daylight, his city moved fast to make it disappear — and put him on leave the same day.
Lance Arnold has run the Broken Arrow Police Department — Oklahoma’s fourth-largest city, 110,000-plus residents — for seven years. In mid-October he was placed on paid administrative leave, and the city would not say why. According to his attorney, Sarah McAmis, no one has told Arnold what he is accused of. She says he received a letter ordering him not to discuss the investigation, and that the inquiry “looks like a threat to his job.”
The email, and what it erased
The reason surfaced through a records request filed under the Oklahoma Open Records Act. Back in March, Arnold emailed officers his own rules for entering homes: officers could enter a house to make an arrest on probable cause alone. No warrant. No consent. No emergency. Just suspicion.
That position collides with the constitutional rule the Supreme Court set for police entering homes to arrest — the warrant requirement, with narrow exceptions for consent and true emergencies. Prosecutors and defense attorneys have fought over that line for decades; a chief’s own email waving it off was not policy anyone had voted on.
Hours after the leave announcement, City Manager David Spurgeon issued a directive erasing the chief’s advice — declaring the email “not policy, not procedure, not guidance,” and that no officer should rely on it. The city’s legal department reviewed the matter, officers were retrained on warrantless home entries, and a city attorney attended the retraining. This week, KJRH confirmed the city quietly corrected the guidance once the records request made it public: officers may not enter a home to make an arrest unless there is a warrant, valid consent, or a true emergency.
Approved before, investigated after
Arnold’s attorney points out an awkward wrinkle: the city reviewed and approved the training materials his office produced before the email ever went out — and Arnold says he wants a fair investigation. The rescinding directive, though, landed the same day as the leave.
The internal investigation continues. No charges, no termination decision, and still no public explanation of what Arnold is actually accused of. If that changes — or if it emerges that any case leaned on an entry made under his email — this story has a next chapter.