Ex-USVI Police Chief Winsbut McFarlande Arrested 2 Days After Hospital Hired Him
The man who led the U.S. Virgin Islands Police Department as its territorial chief was arrested Friday — two days after a hospital announced it had hired him to run its police and security operation.
Winsbut McFarlande Sr. surrendered to VIPD on an outstanding warrant and was charged with simple assault and disturbance of the peace for allegedly slapping a man at a Williams Delight residence on St. Croix. He posted $500 bail and faces an advice-of-rights hearing Monday in Kingshill Superior Court.
The timing is the story. On November 11, Luis Hospital announced it had hired McFarlande to lead its Police and Security Department — his second tour there, according to his career history. Two days later, he was in custody. The hospital has not said whether the job is still his.
This is not the first time McFarlande’s conduct made the record. In 2017, while serving as territorial chief, consent-decree monitors documented him punching a handcuffed prisoner inside a mobile police station at the Cruzan Christmas Festival Village. No use-of-force report was filed — the incident only surfaced because the man in cuffs complained. The investigation substantiated it. McFarlande resigned eight days after the punch, two days after the finding, before the department could fire him.
His career arc: acting St. Croix chief in 2007, replaced, roughly nine years as a security contractor at Luis Hospital, back as St. Croix chief in June 2016, then appointed territorial chief by the governor in July 2017 — the same year as the documented punch. The Virgin Islands police department has operated under a consent decree since 2009, with federal monitors tracking use-of-force reporting.
Monday’s hearing is the next move. A former top cop facing a judge over a slap — two days after getting hired to run hospital security — is the kind of pattern the consent decree was supposed to end.