Pensacola Officer Matthew Baxter Out Of Jail After Posting Bond
CASE UPDATE: The Pensacola police officer at the center of one of Florida’s strangest criminal cases is out of jail. Matthew Baxter — the cop investigators say bought pills in uniform while driving his own patrol car — posted bond this week and walked, while 40 felony counts from his second arrest are still hanging over him.
Baxter was first booked October 14 on twenty counts related to bestiality material after FDLE and Escambia County investigators pulled data from his department iPad. Then on Monday, the same agencies came back with a second arrest: forty new counts, including possession of child abuse material and sexual battery counts, after a deeper dive into more than 1,800 files stored on his devices. Florida’s Agriculture and Consumer Services Inspector General joined the arrest team.
Court records listed his bond at three hundred thousand dollars. Records show he posted one hundred forty five thousand — the standard ten percent route — and walked out of the Escambia County jail. He remains out of custody while every count is pending.
For the first time in this case, we can show you his face. Florida’s booking-photo exemption for law enforcement (F.S.S. 119.071) kept his jail photo sealed — both of his mugshots came out as black silhouettes. But the arrest report story published this week by NorthEscambia.com includes an arrest escort photo where Baxter is fully visible, in cuffs, being led by an officer in a tactical vest. That’s the image above.
The investigation is still moving. FDLE says its work remains active and additional charges are possible — the same warning that preceded arrest number two. No federal charges have been announced.
The fallout inside the department keeps spreading. Chief Eric Winstrom called the missing polygraph record from Baxter’s 2023 hiring an “anomaly” — the test was never completed or never filed — and now says the department is reviewing every officer’s background file. Winstrom previously described the case as a break of public trust in the department.
Baxter had also worked private security at A.K. Suter Elementary School through an off-duty arrangement. The school district says there is no indication any of the seized images involve students. Parents at the school learned of the arrest from news coverage.
And the charges themselves keep getting stranger the deeper investigators dig: twenty counts tied to bestiality material, twenty more including child abuse material possession, sexual battery counts — and a set of restroom photos taken of adult men who never knew they were being photographed.
We’ve followed this case from arrest one. Bond is not a verdict. When the next shoe drops — plea, trial date, or that federal question — you’ll see it here.