Ohio Police Chief Brian Perry Ordered Officers To Ticket Everyone – Village Report
In a village of roughly 1,300 people in Brown County, Ohio, the police chief ordered his officers to ticket everyone they pulled over — and the proof came from his own phone.
A 12-page investigative report prepared by the law firm Jackson Lewis, dated November 5 and commissioned by the Village of Sardinia itself, examined a dozen allegations against Chief Brian Perry and his five-officer department. On the core question, investigators sided with the complaints: Perry directed officers to cite everyone they stopped, discouraged warnings, monitored citation counts, and discussed monthly ticket expectations with revenue in mind.
The text messages attributed to Perry in the report did the most damage. “I just want you all to write everyone,” one read. Another set the bar at a citation for anyone traveling at least 9 mph over the limit. A third referenced $275 generated from a single traffic stop. Officers Zachary Smith and Dakotah Brown told investigators Perry expected five or six tickets per shift — a fixed quota, which would violate Ohio law. Investigators stopped short of substantiating the specific quota number, but substantiated the directive that eliminated officer discretion entirely.
The whole department has been on paid administrative leave since March 27, with the Brown County Sheriff’s Office handling every call in the village since. The investigation and leave salaries have cost taxpayers more than $130,000, at law-firm rates running $390 to $925 an hour.
Then the report turned to the database. A Sardinia lieutenant ran a criminal history check on village councilman Dean Vaughn through Ohio’s Law Enforcement Gateway on January 13 — with no police report and no legitimate law-enforcement purpose behind it. Vaughn was one of two councilmembers who had received complaints about Perry earlier this year. Photographs of the records circulated inside the department, and copies of Vaughn’s information were later mailed to local businesses — the sender never determined. Investigators concluded the search and distribution were improper and potentially unlawful, though they could not establish it was retaliation.
An affidavit from Officer Brown, filed in the run-up to the shutdown, layers on allegations that remain unresolved: that Perry told officers to let his girlfriend go without a ticket after a stop, and that he instructed an officer to lie under oath. Brown’s affidavit outlined eleven incidents in total, closing with claims of cover-up and retaliation from upper management.
The findings land while Perry and the village already face two federal lawsuits alleging retaliation against people who challenged the department — filed by the same officers who blew the whistle. And it is not the village’s first brush with federal prosecutors: its former mayor was charged in 2021 with embezzling roughly $700,000.
Perry still holds the chief’s title. No criminal charges have been announced. He remains on paid leave while the village decides what comes next, and the report urges village leadership to address every finding. Until then, the sheriff runs the streets of Sardinia.
Town, courthouse and map photos: Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0, CC BY 2.0, public domain). Chief photo: Village of Sardinia website.